New York Sports Betting Market Flourishes During March Madness

Grant Mitchell
By: Grant Mitchell
04/02/2024
Industry
Basketball news

Highlights

  • New York sportsbooks took nearly $540 million in bets in one week
  • New York claimed nearly $16 million in tax revenue in one week
  • The Final Four is shaping up to be a betting bonanza 

March Madness fever nudged the Big Apple into one of its most impressive weeks of sports betting since the state market opened in January 2022. 

March Madness earned its name through, well, the complete opposite of normality. While it’s normal for New York sports betting to produce eye-watering totals, the New York Gaming Commission (NYGC) reported a mammoth $539.6 million in total wagers on the week that ended on March 24.

The enormous handle was complemented by $31.2 million in gross gaming in a true standout week for New York sports betting sites.

New York on top 

The American Gaming Association estimated that sports bettors would risk a record $2.72 billion at legal sportsbooks during March Madness, well above even the total reached during the Super Bowl.

The NYGC’s report not only confirmed the AGA’s suspicions but marked the second-largest week of New York sports betting since the state market opened, just behind the total reached during the week ending Jan. 23, 2022.

FanDuel led all nine New York operators with a $244.8 million handle. DraftKings was next in line with $174.4 million before a clear drop-off separating Caesars ($48.2 million), BetMGM ($30.2 million), and others.

  • FanDuel NY: $244,835,753
  • DraftKings NY: $174,377,327
  • Caesars Sportsbook NY: $48,170,660
  • BetMGM NY: $30,196,250
  • Fanatics Sportsbook: $18,419,492
  • BetRivers: $18,394,608
  • Resorts World: $2,235,105
  • Bally Bet: $2,415,375
  • WynnBET: $567,522

FanDuel also led the way in gross gaming revenue with a high mark of nearly $14 million, followed again by DraftKings, Caesars, and BetMGM.

  • FanDuel: $13,967,654
  • DraftKings: $10,329,997
  • Caesars: $2,919,476
  • BetMGM: $1,435,859
  • Fanatics Sportsbook: $1,245,737
  • BetRivers: $944,749
  • Resorts World: $200,666
  • Bally Bet: $74,746
  • WynnBET: $37,601 

 The $539.6 million statewide handle represented a 21.2% increase on the $445.3 million total reached during the week that ended on March 17, two days before the First Four kicked off the NCAA Tournament.

The $31.2 million in revenue also resulted in $15.9 million in tax revenue for the state based on the state’s 51% tariff, tied for the highest of any state in America.

The Final Four beckons 

The next NYGC report will contain totals related to the period during the Sweet 16 and Elite Eight, both of which were memorable times for bracketologists, sports bettors, and basketball fans.

The 11-seed North Carolina State Wolfpack upset No. 2 Marquette and No. 1 Duke as DJ Burns Jr. and company moved on and set up a date with No. 1 Purdue in the Final Four. This path is eerily similar to the one they took in 1983, when they pulled off several upsets, including one against a team led by a 7-foot-4 multi-time National Player of the Year winner (just like Purdue’s Zach Edey), en route to a national championship. 

NC State only went 9-11 in ACC play but won nine straight games, seven of those coming as underdogs. A bettor who risked $100 on the NC State moneyline in each of those games would be up $1,834. 

While the Wolfpack were busting brackets and winning the hearts of Americans everywhere, the UConn Huskies continued their unrelenting dominance with commanding wins against No. 5 San Diego State University and No. 3 Illinois, during which they broke off a 30-0 run.

The Huskies are huge favorites to win the tournament at -185 at FanDuel Sportsbook. Purdue and Edey are second in line at +190 before a chasm separates the top two from Alabama (+1300) and NC State (+2000). 

Purdue is a 9.5-point favorite (-450 moneyline) against NC State at FanDuel. UConn is an -11.5 and -720 on the moneyline against Alabama.

Top US Betting Sites

1
Top Choice

New players only | 21+ | Must bet $10+ | Paid in Bonus Bets | Bonus Bets expire in 7 days | Bonus Bets not included in winnings | Full T&C apply

2

New players only | 21+ | Deposit required. Bonus Bets available for use upon settlement of qualifying bet. Returns exclude Bonus Bets wager.

3

New players only | 21+ | Must deposit $10+ | Use bonus code SPORTS | Free Bet expire after 14 days | Free Bet not included in winnings | Full T&C apply

4

New players only | 21+ | Must bet $20+ | PAID IN BONUS BETS | Free Bet expire after 7 days | Free Bet not included in winnings | Full T&C apply

5

Must be a new verified Betway patron & present in OH. 21+. Make total qualifying deposits of $20+, place your first wager after account opening of $20+ with odds of at least –300 (1.33)) and receive $40 as bonus bet funds. Wager must be settled within 7 days from new account opening. Qualifying wager restrictions apply. Any bonus bet funds earned must be used within 7 days of receipt. Bonus bet funds are not the same as cash, must be used in the Sportsbook, and are subject to restrictions. Promo subject to full T&Cs. Gambling problem? Call/text 1-800-GAMBLER.

Top US Casinos

1
100% Deposit Match UP TO $1,000 + $20 ON THE HOUSE

New players only | 21+ | Must deposit $10+ | x15 wagering requirements | Bonus expires after 30 days | Full T&C apply 

2
100% New Player Bonus of up to $100

New players only | 21+ | Deposit min. $10. Max. bonus $100. 20x wagering (game weighting, table coverage and max. bet rules apply) on deposit and bonus to make the bonus balance withdrawable. Time limits and T&Cs apply. *Please note, all currency amounts are displayed in USD.

3
100% DEPOSIT MATCH UP $500 IN BONUS MONEY

New players only | 21+ | Must deposit $10+ | with a 1x playthrough after entering deposit code- CASINOBACK | on first 24 hours of play | Full T&C apply

4
100% DEPOSIT MATCH UP TO $1,000 + $20 ON THE HOUSE

New players only | 21+ | Deposit required. Bonus Bets available for use upon settlement of qualifying bet. Returns exclude Bonus Bets wager. 

5
50% DEPOSIT MATCH UP TO $1,000 as CASINO BONUS

New players only | 21+ | Must deposit $10+ | x30 wagering requirements | Minimum wager $0.1 | Bonus expires after 30 days | Full T&C apply

6
100% DEPOSIT MATCH UP TO $500 + 500 FREE SPINS

New players only | 21+ | Must deposit $20+ | Apply on first deposit only | x15 wagering requirements | Bonus expires after 7 days | Full T&C apply

7
100% DEPOSIT MATCH UP TO $1,000 + 25 FREE SPINS

New players only | 21+ | Must deposit $10+ | x15 wagering requirements | Bonus expires after 30 days | Full T&C apply 

8
500 Free Spins And 100% Deposit Match Up To $1000

New players only | 21+ | Must deposit $50  |  Full T&C apply

Grant is a sports and sports betting journalist who prides himself in his up-to-the-minute reporting on the latest events in the industry. A member of Virginia Tech’s 2021 graduating class, he has quickly put together an impressive portfolio since moving to the professional world full-time. Grant’s favorite sports to cover are basketball and both types of football (American and soccer), and he is pushing written, audio, and video content. He has been employed by companies as highly regarded as Forbes and continues on a great trajectory in the industry. When he’s not on the clock, you can find Grant at the gym, looking for adventures, or hanging out with his family.